Cement is the fundamental material of the construction industry used in manufacturing and other construction activities. Understanding the different types of cement is important for selecting the appropriate cement. The two most widely used cement in various projects are Ordinary Portland Cement (OPC) and Portland Pozzolana Cement (PPC).
They serve similar functions, but they have varied properties, compositions and applications. For strong buildings to mega structures, the primary concern of engineers and builders is to ensure strong concrete foundations. And for the concrete structure to be robust, the right type of cement choice is vital. Basically, OPC is the most used cement. If you study the difference between OPC and PPC, you can make the right decision by picking the best cement for your project. In this article, we examine the differences between OPC and PPC cement and discuss their uses in various construction applications.
Difference Between OPC and PPC Cement You Must Know
The basic OPC & PPC cement difference is in their chemical composition. so, let’s explore their differences below-
Ordinary Portland Cement (OPC)
OPC consists of chemical components like calcium silicate, aluminate, and ferrites. OPC attains early strength due to the rapid hydration of clinker minerals resulting in a denser microstructure. During the hydration, a quick reaction takes place between water and calcium silicates leading to faster strength development. In addition, it has higher fineness, which contributes to its faster strength gain and higher initial strength. OPC is available in three grades such as OPC 33, OPC 43, and OPC 53. This grade represents different categories of strength, such as 33 MPa, 43 MPa, and 53 Mpa respectively after 28 days of curing.
It’s higher early strength, making it suitable for projects that need a quick removal of framework and a faster construction schedule. The workability of OPC is good, but it requires more water compared to PPC for the same level of workability. Ordinary Portland cement has lower resistance to sulfate attack and other chemical reactions.
OPC is more expensive than PPC because of the higher cost of clinker production. It generates a higher carbon footprint due to the energy-intensive clinker production process.
Portland Pozzolana Cement (PPC)
PPC is mixed with OPC clinker and pozzolanic materials like fly ash, volcanic ash, or silica fumes. The development of a denser microstructure happens over time as the pozzolanic reactions proceed, which leads to reduced porosity and increased durability. It has a slower reaction, which involves the reaction of pozzolanic materials with calcium hydroxide released during OPC hydration. PPC has low strength gain, but it eventually reaches similar or higher strength than OPC over a long curing period. It has lower fineness compared to OPC resulting in slower strength development. PPC does not have grades, its strength matches with the OPC33 grade.
In PPC, because of the pozzolanic materials, it offers greater workability, which enhances its cohesiveness and reduces bleeding. It has greater resistance to chemical attacks, including sulfate and chloride penetration. Because of the pozzolanic reaction that reduces porosity and permeability, PPC is different from OPC in the case of chemical resistance.
Considering the price difference between OPC and PPC cement, PPC is more economical as it uses industrial by-products that reduce production costs. Industrial by-products like fly ash, reduce the reliance on clinker. Thus, PPC lowers the overall carbon emissions by being more environmentally friendly.
Comparison Table of Portland Cement and Pozzolana Cement
All the details about the difference between pozzolana and Portland cement are provided in the following table.
Description | Ordinary Portland cement (OPC) | Portland Pozzolana Cement (PPC) |
Composition | It is composed of clinker produced by heating limestone and clay at high temperatures and a small amount of gypsum to control setting time. | It is made by mixing OPC clinker with silicious or aluminous substances that react with calcium hydroxide to form compounds having cementitious properties. |
Components / Materials | It has calcium, silicates, aluminates and ferrites. | Pozzolanic materials include volcanic ash, fly ash and silica fume. |
Setting Time | Its initial setting time is around 30 minutes, and the final setting time is about 10 hours. | Its initial setting time is roughly 30 minutes to an hour and a final setting time of up to 12 hours. |
Fineness | Higher fineness and higher initial strength. | Lower fineness and much higher final strength. |
Early Strength | Higher early strength. | Lower early strength. |
Chemical Resistance | Less resistant to sulfate attack and other chemical reactions. | Greater resistance to chemical attacks. |
Resistance to Cracking | More prone to thermal and shrinkage cracks due to higher heat of hydration. | Has lower heat of hydration, resulting in a reduced risk of thermal and shrinkage cracks. |
Carbon Footprint | Higher carbon footprint. | Less carbon footprint. |
Cost | More expensive. | Less expensive. |
Grades | OPC is available in three grades. | PPC does not have grades. |
Durability | The difference between OPC and PPC is that OPC is less durable compared to PPC. | PPC has more durability than other cement. |
Uses of OPC and PPC
Uses of OPC
- OPC is ideal for high-rise buildings because of the high early strength gain, which is important for the construction speed and load-bearing requirements of these structures.
- It can be used in road pavements, bridges and flyovers. These structures need fast setting time, which is necessary to open them for use quickly.
- OPC is ideal for precast concrete products like beams, columns and slabs.
- It is suitable for concreting in colder climates where cold weather may slow down the setting process for other types of cement.
Uses of PPC
- PPC can be used for mass concrete work like dams, retaining walls, and foundations. It has lower heat of hydration, which reduces the risk of thermal cracking.
- Another OPC and PPC difference is that PPC is highly resistant to sulphate and chloride attacks. Thus, making it suitable for marine structures like piers, docks, and underwater construction.
- PPC has a reduced risk of cracking and slower setting time. So, PPC is suitable for masonry and plastering work. PPC provides a smoother finish and enhanced durability.
- OPC and PPC difference is that PPC has resistance to aggressive environments and good durability. It is essential in the construction of hydraulic structures like canals, reservoirs, and sewage treatment plants.
Conclusion
When choosing cement for the construction project, depending on specific requirements, consider OPC and PPC cement differences before selecting. PPC is ideal for constructions that require improved durability and long-term strength, while OPC is better suitable for projects requiring quick setting and strong early strength. By being aware of OPC & PPC cement differences, engineers and builders can choose the appropriate cement type, enhancing the life and sustainability of their constructions. For further guidance before starting your project, don’t forget to consult the experts at Brick & Bolt, as they will provide you with correct information, and the team of engineers and contractors can help you build your dream project.